PortlandWiki:Logo development: Difference between revisions

From PortlandWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(→‎Versions: +versions 2-5)
(→‎Discussion: moving discussion to talk page since discussion is beginning there and it's more standard anyway)
Line 37: Line 37:


== Discussion ==
== Discussion ==
=== Colors ===
Please give feedback on what you want to see in a logo, or what you like or dislike about the proposed logos! The place to add your comments is on this page's talk/discussion page, [[PortlandWiki talk:Logo]].
* I feel that there should be only two colors besides black, as more tend to give a jumbled and chaotic impression. The rose/pink, while appropriate once you know the reason, may look red, and therefore angry (as pointed out by Arthur from the November WikiWednesday). Making it less red and more pink would solve that problem, but introduces the problem of being more, well, pink. Blue and green, as used in the flag of Portland, may be the solution. Teresa helped me research this; the City of Portland's explanation of the colors is the blue represents Portland's two rivers, and the green is for "the forests and our green City". Sounds fine to me, and they are aesthetically pleasing (if slightly dull) colors. Thoughts? -[[User:Kotra|kotra]] 05:49, 5 November 2009 (UTC)
 
=== Motifs ===
* I'd like to include some sort of "confluence" motif, representing the disparate peoples and ideas of our city coming together. The first logo I think alludes to that, but not particularly strongly or obviously. Not entirely sure yet how to adapt it to emphasize confluence more, or what other ideas would better illustrate this, so suggestions are welcome. -[[User:Kotra|kotra]] 05:49, 5 November 2009 (UTC)
 
=== Text ===
* Are we "PortlandWiki" or "Portland Wiki"? This is fairly crucial, since the first logo has them separated into two words. -[[User:Kotra|kotra]] 05:49, 5 November 2009 (UTC)
*:Well, judging by the [[PortlandWiki|main page]] and most other uses I've seen, it's probably "PortlandWiki". My next version will make it one word. -[[User:Kotra|kotra]] 22:03, 4 December 2009 (UTC)

Revision as of 20:45, 24 December 2009

This page is for designing and discussing the PortlandWiki logo.

Versions

1.

Flag of Portland

This is the first and currently used logo. It was created as a placeholder until something better was made. The colors are shades of a type of "rose" or pink/red, connoting Portland's "city of roses" nature. The design is derived from the Flag of Portland. The two curved extensions from the square have no particular meaning (got any ideas?).


2.

PortlandWiki is all one word now, reflecting the most common usage here. Since that makes the word longer, it has been moved into a "stacked" configuration, to display better in constrained-width locations (which are not uncommon). The emblem has been made more stylized and less blocky (partially to reduce vaguely swastika-ish bits), but still has no particular meaning.


3.

It's supposed to call to mind a rose, as this is the city of roses. I may have failed at that though, as it sort of resembles a hand for me (which I'm not sure if is a good or bad thing). It may also recollect the "confluence" theme. If a rose motif like this is a promising idea, it might be worthwhile to explore a few more variations. One might also recognize the bottom "petal" is based on the original version (and, hence, the Portland flag), but I doubt anyone would really notice that.


4.

It's a cloud, because, well, Portland is known for its clouds and rain. It's a somewhat cartoony style, which might not match the "PortlandWiki" font, but perhaps might get across that we aren't totally serious and that there is a little more tolerance for casualness and humor in our tone than, say, Wikipedia.


5.

Same as 4, but gray-blue. This would be a more accurate color for our clouds, as blood-red clouds in Portland are only seen in the occasional judgment day/armageddon/army of the antichrist bloodbaths that are somewhat rare these days.

Discussion

Please give feedback on what you want to see in a logo, or what you like or dislike about the proposed logos! The place to add your comments is on this page's talk/discussion page, PortlandWiki talk:Logo.